NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Semi Permanent Liquid Liner (Various Shades)

This is the best waterproof eyeliner I have come across in many years of hunting. It really does the job for my watery eyes. It is thick and so is the brush, but by pressing the wand against the side when removing you can flatten it to get a good sharp point. Easy to remove with Almay eye make-up remover pads - as good as the late-lamented Boots eye make-up remover pads, now sadly discontinued and much missed.

This is really good and does last (hard to get off!) and it's a really nice shade of brown - I've been searching and it's hard to find actual brown! The only thing I don't like about it is around my old eyes, it is hard to be precise and I have hooded eyes so since it takes a while to dry down it is something I have to sit for a while with a fan making sure to not smudge. Like I say though, once it's on it's ON. I'd definitely repurchase as I've had this for months and it's showing no signs of drying up or going weird and I use it most days. It can also go in your waterline too.

I have bought many of this eye liner, apples really well and lasts! Doesn't smudge once dried. My go to eyeliner!